Altarpiece of St George
- Place of origin:
Valencia, Spain (painted)
First quarter of the 15th century (painted)
Master of the Centenar (Attributed to, production)
Marçal de Sas, Andrés (Formerly ascribed to, production)
- Materials and Techniques:
tempera and gilt on pine panel
- Museum number:
- Gallery location:
Raphael, room 48a
This large altarpiece is a fine example of the Valencian school during the International Gothic Style in the first quarter of the 15th century. It was traditionally attributed to the German painter established in Valencia, Andrès Marçal de Sas (ca.1393-1410) although this attribution is still subject to debate and leads to more cautiously call the artist responsible for this work 'Master of the Centenar' according to the provenance of the retable most likely executed for the chapel of the Confraternity of the Centenar de la Ploma.
The altarpiece illustrates the legend of the St George, a Christian warrior saint, said to have lived at the end of the 3rd century. It is composed of 3 superimposed central panels surmounted by the Holy Spirit and Christ enthroned flanked by two prophets. On each side are depicted 10 scenes of the life of the saint, combining two different narrative cycles: the victory of St George against the dragon and the martyrdom of the saint while the predella panel illustrates 10 scenes of the passion of Christ.
Large altarpiece composed of 20 panels representing scenes from the legend of St George with a predella illustrating 10 scenes from the Passion of Christ; on the upper register is represented the Christian hierarchy with Christ, the Virgin and Child, prophets and apostles while the all composition is subdivided by full-length figures of saints and prophets.
Place of Origin
Valencia, Spain (painted)
First quarter of the 15th century (painted)
Master of the Centenar (Attributed to, production)
Marçal de Sas, Andrés (Formerly ascribed to, production)
Materials and Techniques
tempera and gilt on pine panel
Height: 6.6 m altarpiece, Width: 5.5 m altarpiece
Object history note
Purchased on the Paris market by J.C. Robinson for the South Kensington Museum , 1864
Historical significance: This altarpiece is traditionally attributed to the German artist established in Valencia, Spain, Andrès Marçal de Sas (ca.1393-1410) (Post, 1930) even though this attribution is not entirely convincing as it mainly relies on a consistent feature of the retable, the prominent long nose seen by various scholars as the hall-mark of Marçal de Sas (on the ground of a comparison with a fragment of the Incredulity of St Thomas, Valencia Cathedral Museum, the only surviving work of the eight listed under his name). Despite an obvious unity of style, it has been considered as the work of several hands: Pedro Nicolau, the main associate of Marçal de Sas, Gonzalo Perez and Miguel Alcaniz have all been suggested as collaborators in this work.
Recent studies have more cautiously proposed to identify the artist responsible for the execution of the altarpiece as the Master of the Centenar (Heriard Dubreuil, 1987). This name was forged on the provenance of the work which was probably destined to the Confraternity of the Valencian civic militia dedicated to St George and called in fact the 'Centenar de la Ploma'. The company was originally founded as a company of hundred ('centenar') archers in 1365. Their insignia, a crossbow, stands alongside the cross of St George at the top of the outer frame. The Confraternity was abolished in 1711, when Philip V abrogated the local laws and institutions of the kingdom and city of Valencia.
The style of the artist who was probably a direct follower of Marçal de Sas, if not Marçal himself, suggested the influence of early 15th-century Franco-Flemish artists such as Jacques Coene (act. 1398-1404), sometimes identified as the Boucicaut Master (documented 1402).
The altarpiece depicts the legend of the Christian warrior and martyr St George, said to have been born in Capaddocia, Asia Minor and to have died at Lydda in Palestine about the end of the 3rd century. He is venerated as the patron saint of several cities and countries in Europe including Venice and England. St George appears to be the patron saint of Catalonia from the very beginning while the region was taking shape. The cult of this saint spread with the conquest of new territories by the Counts of Barcelona in the 13th century. The city of Valencia however devoted a cult to St Vincent Ferrer.
The legend of St George is narrated in Jacobus of Voragine's Golden Legend (13th century) but also with variations in several apocryphal texts. In the present case, it seems that the artist followed a 14th century Catalan version (see R. D'Alos-Moner, Sant Jordi Patro de Catalunya, Barcelona, 1926, pp. 16-61), in which appear additional torture scenes here illustrated .
The legend of St George is partially similar to that of Perseus as he fought a dragon by the sea-shore, outside the walls of a city, in order to rescue the king's daughter who was being offered as a sacrifice. These scenes are represented in the upper registers (from left to right):
- As a saint warrior St George is dub a knight by the Virgin and exhibits his main attribute, the red cross.
- The following panel shows a child and a ram sacrificed to the dragon
- The princess of Silene is chosen as the next sacrifice.
The larger panel in the lower centre shows the rescue of the Princess while the last panel of the upper register on the right illustrates the subduing of the dragon led into the city in order to be put to death there. The dragon is traditionally considered a symbol of evil struck down by the saint warrior, which illustrates therefore the struggle between good and evil. The saint then baptised the King and the people of Silene (far left of the middle register).
A few examples of narrative cycles dedicated to St George have survived such as in the Oratory of St George, Padua, and an altarpiece now in the Wallraf-Richartz-Museum, Cologne, but scenes illustrating the martyr of the saint, described in the lower half of the altarpiece, are fairly rare and occur principally in churches or institutions of which he is the patron.
According to the legend, St George was a Roman soldier under the reign of Diocletian (244-311). When Diocletian promulgated an edict against the Christians, St George stood up and defended his faith before the Emperor. This scene is illustrated in the panel next to the baptism of the people of Silene. In spite of the Emperor's efforts to make him renounce his faith, St George remained constant and was therefore sentenced to death. The subsequent tortures, from which St George resuscitated three times, are illustrated in the lower registers as follows (from left to right) - the present order resulting from a rearrangement of the panels after the restoration undertaken in 1969-72 :
- St George is tortured on a table;
- St George is put in prison;
- St George is tied between two wheels;
- St George is tied between two posts and swan in half ;
- St George is tortured in a cauldron;
- St George prays;
- St George is drawn naked through the city;
- St George is eventually beheaded.
The central panel illustrating the defeat of the Moors against the Christian army led by James I of Aragon (1213-1276) at the battle of El Puig in 1237 does not belong to the story of St George but illustrates an important episode in the formation of Catalonia. Legend has it that the victory was due to the providential help of the Saint who appeared to James I while fighting the Moors.
A parallel between the two superimposed central panels is therefore evident: St George striking the devil is implicitly associated with James I striking the Moors and commonly called 'Infidels' as they did not share the same religious faith as the Christians. J. Berg Sobré points out that the Islamic force is depicted as a bunch of ugly warriors, consistent with the militant anti-Muslim sentiment during the re-conquest of Spain. The retable illustrates thus the victory of Christian faith over the devil and the Muslims to which they are implicitly identified.
The retable is therefore dominated by the Christian hierarchy, which frames the legend of St George in the upper and lower sections while full-length figures of saints and prophets divide each scenes. In the upper registers are indeed represented the Holy Spirit, followed by Christ holding the Orb underneath, flanked by the two prophets Moses and Elijah. Immediately below, the first of the central panels from the top is the Virgin nursing the Child crowned by Christ and surrounded by angels. On each side are represented the four evangelists (from left to right): St John, St Luke, St Mark and St Matthew. In the lower section, the predella below comprises 10 scenes of the Passion (from left to right): Agony in the Garden, Betrayal, Christ before Caiaphas, Flagellation, Mocking of Christ, Christ bearing the Cross, Crucifixion, Deposition, Entombment and Resurrection.
According to J. Berg Sobré, the altarpiece of St George is a typical example of the Valencian retable format of around 1400, in which the large proportions of the various components appear as a predominant feature. In this respect, some of the impact of the individual paintings is lost on the spectator. The altarpiece of St George appears as a fine example of the 'International Gothic Style' which combine medieval and early Renaissance elements. For instance the extensive use of gilt and ornamental plaster shaping decorative elements such as mullions, friezes, and canopies, of which consists the almost entire background, look still medieval in style whereas the painted architectural features and the thrones are reminiscent of models from the Italian and Flemish early Renaissance.
Typical of the International Gothic is also the new attention to realism and nature, especially in the representation of plants and animals. The violent expression and twisted pose of the figures as well as the realism of the torture scenes pervaded with horrific details are particularly striking. Analogously the palette appeared richer and more varied than that of the preceding Romanesque period, including vermilion, cadmium, violet, green, lilac, ochre, white, grey, and yellow. Hence their sumptuous appearance and curious combination of realistic details and unworldly idealism.
Historical context note
In Italy, the altar became a primary setting for painting on panel - hence the appellation 'altarpiece' - a format developed in Western art from the example of Byzantine icons. An early format consisted in gabled vertical panels representing a full-length saint flanked by scenes of his or her life and soon developed to include several individual compartments to form a polyptych which frames could become increasingly elaborate. They eventually transformed the altarpiece into an architectonic structure resembling in detail and spatial principles the façades of contemporary full-scale Gothic architecture. In Italy such altarpieces were usually made of wood and painted, while in northern Europe they were commonly executed in stone. A new type of altarpiece soon appeared in 15th-century Italy, known as pala,, and was closer to a framed picture. In the interest of clarity and unity, numerous medieval screens separating the choir and high altar from the nave were removed.
The religious reforms of the 16th century brought new attention and some important changes to the form and function of the altarpiece. Under Protestant auspices, the altarpiece iconography was restricted to subjects well-suited to the sacrament celebrated at the altar, such as the Last Supper while the dynamic qualities that characterize Baroque art brought important changes to altarpiece design. Important altarpieces consisting of a single painting or relief continued to be made, but increasingly architecture was used as the theatrical setting for the three-dimensional display of the altarpiece's subject in sculpture.
Altarpieces adorned both high altars and side altars. High altars often carried large altarpieces with elaborate programmes while side altars served a more private piety and their altarpieces were often endowed by private individuals.
Tempera and gilt on pine panel, 'Altarpiece of St George', Master of the Centenar, Valencia, first quarter of the 15th century
Bibliographic References (Citation, Note/Abstract, NAL no)
C.M. Kauffmann,Catalogue of Foreign Paintings, I. Before 1800. London: Victoria and Albert Museum, 1973, pp. 180-84, cat. no. 221.
The following is the full text of the entry:
MARZAL DE SAS (active 1393-after 1410)
Spanish (Valencian) School
He presumably came from Saxony, as he is recorded as 'Mestre Marcal de Sas, pintor Alamany' (the German painter) in Valencian documents. During the period 1393-1405 he received eight major commissions and was clearly one of the most important painters in Valencia. Unfortunately only one fragment of his work survives: the panel of the Incredulity of St Thomas in Valencia Cathedral Museum, which has been identified as having formed part of a retable of St Thomas painted by Marzal for St Thomas's Chapel in the Cathedral in 1400. The last documentary record of him is in 1410, when he was suffering from 'grave poverty and illness' and received free lodgings from the city, but his survival into the second decade of the century is suggested by the fact that his daughter, who married in 1430, was probably born in ca. 1412-15. The style of the Incredulity of St Thomas has been described as Germanic and may be linked with Bohemian painting of ca. 1380.
Lit. For the documents see J. Sanchis y Sivera, Pintores medievales en Valencia,1930, pp. 48-52; L. Cervero y Gomis, Pintores valentinos: su cronologia y documentation (Separata de Anales del Centro de Cultura Valenciana), Valencia, 1964, p. 121 ff.; id. in Archivo de Arte Valenciano, xxvii, 1956, p, 107.
For a discussion of his work see below under Post and Saralegui.
Ascribed to MARZAL de Sas
ALTAR-PIECE OF ST GEORGE
Central panels: ST GEORGE FIGHTING THE DRAGON; A CHRISTIAN ARMY UNDER JAMES I OF ARAGON DEFEATING THE MOORS, WITH THE HELP OF ST GEORGE, AT THE BATTLE OF PUIG (18th October 1237); THE VIRGIN NURSING THE CHILD AND CROWNED BY CHRIST AND ANGELS, SURMOUNTED BY CHRIST WITH THE ORB, FLANKED BY MOSES AND THE HOLY DOVE AT THE VERY TOP.
On the sides: SIXTEEN SCENES OF THE LIFE AND MARTYRDOM OF ST GEORGE, WITH THE FOUR EVANGELISTS SURROUNDED BY ANGELS IN THE UPPER REGISTER.
In the pilasters: TWENTY-FOUR PROPHETS, SOME BEARING SCROLLS INSCRIBED WITH THEIR NAMES.
In the outer frame: TWELVE APOSTLES, separated from each other by panels containing blank squares, which are 19th century replacements; the four squares at the top still contain the original arms: THE CROSSBOW AND THE CROSS OF ST GEORGE.
Predella: THE AGONY IN THE GARDEN, THE BETRAYAL, CHRIST BEFORE CAIAPHAS, THE FLAGELLATION, THE MOCKING, CHRIST BEARING THE CROSS, THE CRUCIFIXION, THE RESURRECTION (the outer two panels have been cut down by a third).
Tempera and gilt on pine
21 ft 9 in. x 18 ft (6.6 x 5.5 m.)
The attribution to Marzal de Sas is due to Post (1930), who pointed to similarities, particularly of facial types, with the Incredulity of St Thomas (1400) in Valencia Cathedral. There are, however, several difficulties involved in this attribution:
1. the St George retable represents a more fully developed stage of the International Gothic style than the Incredulity of St Thomas and should be dated ca. 1410-20. The armour has been dated ca. 1420 (Manu, 1933).
2. Marzal de Sas is recorded as suffering from 'grave poverty and illness' in 1410 and his activity after that date remains conjectural.
3. Our knowledge of his work is based solely on the Incredulity of St Thomas: a small fragment of an altar-piece, now in an almost invisible condition.
Taking these factors into account, it will be seen that the attribution to Marzal de Sas, which has been widely accepted, must remain tentative.
For some time it had been recognized that the order of the panels did not follow the sequence of the story of St George. The confusion had arisen because, within each wing, certain panels had been moved; the extent of dislocation had been limited by the fact that some compartments could not be separated because a single wooden panel had been used for two scenes one below the other. Consequently, when the retable was dismantled for cleaning in 1969-72, a reconstruction was attempted, re-arranging the panels to fit the sequence of the story. In the reconstructed retable the order of scenes follows the text with only one exception;
1 St George armed by the Virgin and angels.
2 Silene, Libya; the dragon threatening the city was pacified by the sacrifice of a man and a sheep.
3 When the lot fell upon the king's daughter, the king protested but was forced to give up his daughter.
4 After St George had pierced the dragon (central panel), he tied it up with the princess's girdle.
5 So impressed were the inhabitants of Silene that the king, queen, princess and 15,000 men were baptised by Bishop Alexander.
6 St George, now in the habit of a Christian, denounced the pagan gods as devils before Dacian, the local ruler.
7 As St George refused to sacrifice to Apollo, he was tortured on a cross, his flesh scraped with iron combs.
8 He was then placed on a table, nailed to it and tied to it with chains and tortured.
9 After this he was put in prison, where Christ and the angels came to him in the night to give him comfort.
10 Dacian ordered the enchanter to mix a strong poison; St George drank it without coming to any harm and, when the enchanter saw his magic overcome by a power stronger than his own, he knelt at the feet of St George and prayed to him to make him a Christian, whereupon Dacian had him executed on the spot. (This is the only scene still out of place in the sequence of the story; it cannot be moved, as it is on the same panel as the scene below.)
11 St George was then tortured between two wheels with sharp points.
12 Dacian ordered him to be tied to two posts and sawn asunder.
13 He was then placed in a cauldron of molten lead, but, with the Lord's protection, he seemed well at ease as though in a bath.
14 St George now pretended to worship the idols but instead prayed for the destruction of the temple.
15 He was then drawn naked through the city.
16 And, finally, beheaded. When this had been done, fire fell from heaven and burnt Dacian and all his servants.
Most of these scenes can be found in the Golden Legend, which was the most popular source of saints' lives in the later Middle Ages, but this does not appear to have been the artist's source. Two of the scenes - St George nailed to the table (scene 8) and sawn asunder (scene 12) - do not appear in the Golden Legend, but are described in the 14th century Catalan version (see R. D'Alos-Moner, Sant Jordi Patro de Catalunya, Barcelona, 1926, pp. 16-61). In various details, also the scenes on the retable fit more closely with this version than with the Golden Legend, which provides a further indication that the artist was using a manuscript close to the Catalan text.
Iconographically, the scene of St George and the dragon follows the standard type of the period and may be compared, for example, with that in the Hours of Marechal de Boucicaut, ca. 1408 (Paris, Musée Jacquemart André, MS. 2, fol. 23). There are relatively few equally extensive cycles of the life of St George earlier than the retable and those that exist (e.g. Altichiero's frescoes in the Oratorio di S. Giorgio in Padua, 1378-84) are not very similar. The closest earlier cycle is contained in a 14th century Passional of Hungarian origin, but Italian in style and character (MS. Vat. Lat, 8541, fols. 54v, 55, 56V); it consists of ten scenes, nine of which are paralleled in the retable. In Spain only one earlier cycle of St George is extant; the altar-piece by Luis Borrassa in. the Convent of Vilafranca del Panades, near Barcelona (c. 1392-1400) and this contains only five scenes of his life. However, two of these are very similar and it seems likely that at least some of the retable's models could be found in contemporary Spain.
It has long been recognized that the insignia at the top of the outer frame - the cross of St George and a crossbow - are those of a Confraternity of Valencian civic militia dedicated to St George and called the 'Centenar de la Ploma', originally founded as a company of 100 archers in 1365. The foundation of the Confraternity followed in 1371 and in 1393 its membership was fixed at 500 men and 600 women. It was a large and wealthy institution and its privileged status in Valencian affairs is indicated by the fact that it served as the custodian of the city banner. The Confraternity was abolished in 1711, when Philip V abrogated the local laws and institutions of the kingdom and city of Valencia.
Chandler Post (iii, p. 58 f.; vi, p. 583) argued that the retable was originally in the Chapel of the Centenar de la Ploma in the Church of St George (S. Jorge), Valencia, which was demolished in the 19th century, and this identification has been widely accepted ever since. However, the altar-piece in this chapel is described in detail by Josef Teixidor in 1767 (Antiquedades de Valencia, ii, Valencia, 1895, p. 98), and from his description it is quite clear that it cannot be identified with the Museum's retable of St George. There is, however, strong evidence that the Museum's retable was originally in the Confraternity's house in the Calle de Ballesters, adjacent to the Church of S. Jorge. This house contained a large chapel some 40 feet high and a description of 1740 mentions a large empty space above the altar where the retable had been. It is likely that the retable was sold when the Confraternity was abolished in 1711.
Condition. Cleaned in 1969-72 and found to be in remarkably good condition.
Prov. Confraternity of the Centenar de la Ploma, Valencia (probably in the Confraternity's house in the Calle de Ballesters until 1711); bought on the Paris art market in 1864.
Lit. A. L. Mayer, Geschichte der Spanischen Malerei, 1922, p. 35 ff., repr.; E. Tormo, Levante, Guias Calpe, Madrid, 1923, p. cxxxiii f.; C. R. Post, A history of Spanish painting, iii, 1930, p. 58 ff., figs. 269-71; L. de Saralegui in Archivo de Arte Valenciano, xix, 1933, p. 36 ff., fig. 1; ibid., xxii, 1936, pp. 32-9, fig. 40 f.; J. G. Mann, 'Notes on the armour worn in Spain .. .' in Archaeologia, lxxxiii, 1933, p. 293, pl. 83; A. Marguillier, Saint Georges, L' Art et les Saints, Paris, n.d., repr. pp. 49, 51; J. Gudiol Ricart, Ars hispania, ix; pintura gotica, Madrid, 1955, p. 143 f., fig. 109 f.; M. de Riquer, L' arnès del cavaller, armes i armadures catalanes medievals, Barcelona, 1968, p. 112, figs. 162, 165; C. M. Kauffmann, 'The Altar-piece of St. George from Valencia' in V. & A. Museum, Yearbook, ii, 1970, pp. 65-100 (with full lit.).
A. L. Mayer, Geschichte der Spanischen Malerei, 1922, p. 35 ff., repr.
E. Tormo, Levante - Guias Calpe, Madrid: 1923, p. cxxxiii f.
C. R. Post, A history of Spanish painting, iii, 1930, p. 58 ff., figs. 269-71.
L. de Saralegui in Archivo de Arte Valenciano, xix, 1933, p. 36 ff., fig. 1.
L. de Saralegui in Archivo de Arte Valenciano, xxii, 1936, pp. 32-9, fig. 40 f.
J. G. Mann, 'Notes on the armour worn in Spain .. .' in Archaeologia, lxxxiii, 1933, p. 293, pl. 83.
A. Marguillier, Saint Georges, L' Art et les Saints, Paris, n.d., repr. pp. 49, 51.
J. Gudiol Ricart, Ars hispania, ix; pintura gotica,Madrid, 1955, p. 143 f., fig. 109 f.
M. de Riquer, L' arnès del cavaller, armes i armadures catalanes medievals, Barcelona, 1968, p. 112, figs. 162, 165.
C. M. Kauffmann, 'The Altar-piece of St. George from Valencia' in V. & A. Museum, Yearbook, ii, 1970, pp. 65-100.
B. Myers, St George and the dragon, unpublished dissertation, New York University, 1933.
M. Heriard Dubreuil, Valencia y el Gotico Internacional, 2 vol., Valencia: 1987, pp. 60, 86, 122-123, 146, fig. 138, 409.
As Master of the Centenar.
J. Berg Sobré, Behind the altar table: the development of the painted retable in Spain, 1350-1500, Columbia:1989, pp. 111-113, 173, 209-211, fig. 64.
A. U. Koch, 'Martin Schongauer, Uberraschende Entdeckungen uber seinen Reiseweg in Spanien' in Weltkunst Oct. 1994, pp.2696-98, fig. 3.
Miquel Juan, Matilde, 'El Gótico Internacional en la ciudad de Valencia. El retablo de san Jorge del Centenar de la Ploma' in Goya, 336 (2011), pp. 191-213.
Gilt; Tempera; Pine
Dragon; St. George; Altarpieces; Silene; James I of Aragon
Christianity; Paintings; Arms & Armour